24

The Cut

May 22, 2020 by Tim

Look, if this Snyder Cut actually turns Justice League into a good movie, I’ll be thrilled to eat crow here. But I think the past few years of blind-faith hype over this thing has written a check that no amount of unused footage, or the man behind the camera, can possibly cash. Slice it up, rearrange it, add some new effects… I don’t think the core vision for this franchise was ever on solid footing to begin with.

I guess we’ll see, though.


59
Leave a Reply

avatar
24 Comment threads
35 Thread replies
2 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
43 Comment authors
Bernie MargolisJetroidW. JamesScottraven0ak Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Blake
Guest
Blake

eRhMaGeRd Ur MoM wAs MaRtHa ToO?!
DC need to get some decent writers, have yet to see a film from them I though was worth the time watching it.

Bookishjon
Guest
Bookishjon

Wonder Woman. Literally only modern DC movie that I’d consider worth the watch.

Hobbess
Guest
Hobbess

Birds of Prey And Harliquinn was good. Aside from the mess of the title. Most people I know with time for TV seem to genuinely love the DC shows. Overall though that still has them batting under .200.

Stephen M Schaefer
Guest
Stephen M Schaefer

The Arrowverse has been pretty solid but I don’t have time in my day for five titles. Mostly we just watch Flash and Legends. And honestly, not bringing in Grant Gustin felt like a missed opportunity. Ezra Miller is a fine actor but Gustin brings so much charm to the role. Also, allegedly, he chokes fewer women outside of bars.

Jéquiyot
Guest
Jéquiyot

I thought Aquaman was pretty good, too.

David.
Guest
David.

Aquaman was an enjoyable summer blockbuster kind of film. To make the dreaded Marvel comparison, while Wonderwoman was about as good, if not better, than anything Marvel has to offer, Aquaman was a bit like the mid-tier films (e.g. Antman, Thor 1, Iron Man 3) – I enjoyed watching them, but I probably wouldn’t watch them again.

Sean Rotter
Guest
Sean Rotter

Visually Aquaman was impressive, acting and writing was dismal for the most part (Jason Momoa is did a pretty good job).

Pulse
Guest
Pulse

they could start by doing the same thing marvel did, turn their comics into movies with a few changes.

Siliarba
Guest
Siliarba

Watch their animated movies, they are for the majority movie gold.

Urazz
Guest
Urazz

I wouldn’t even say writing is the major issue for DC but more that they need to just redo it from scratch and not rush through it this time and focus on the core and A rank stuff first. Don’t do stuff below B rank (Suicide Squad and the Harley Quinn movie were definitely D rank in the comic totem pole at best) until after the first Justice League movie. DC does have some films that show they can have some good writing, Man of Steel was pretty decent and Wonder Woman was good as well and that was before… Read more »

Kaitensatsuma
Guest
Kaitensatsuma

Honestly HISHE would have been a better choice for writing that movie.

rivenhex
Guest
rivenhex

Or at least for finalizing the cut.

Bernie Margolis
Guest
Bernie Margolis

I think the problem is that they hate Superman, who is, was, and always should be the anchor for the Justice League. They prefer Batman, but Batman is a loner. That’s his shtick. How can you have a loner leading a group of superheroes? The twentyteens version of the Justice League ended up being a bunch of loners who barely tolerate each other out of a sense of mutual respect. That’s a far cry from the Super Friends that I grew up with. Scott Meyer explained it really well in 2015: http://www.basicinstructions.net/basic-instructions/2015/6/21/ow-to-explain-what-the-deal-is-with-the-avengers.html TL;DR – Maybe get people who actually like… Read more »

foducool
Guest
foducool

can’t believe I’ve seen comments that people are looking forward to this lol

Bwauder
Guest
Bwauder

For some, getting out of the house to watch ANY new movie beats being stuck at home with momma watching her murderporn “stories”.

Nuno Fernandes
Guest
Nuno Fernandes

Its coming out on HBO Max, not theatres

Pajuka
Guest
Pajuka

Hope and hype are powerful drugs.

Siliarba
Guest
Siliarba

I’m one of the few people who felt the film, while not great, wasn’t bad either and enjoyed it enough to validate watching it. So looking forward to the movie is saying a lot, but I’m definitely interested in it.

Scott
Guest
Scott

I never saw the theatrical version, but I kind of enjoyed the extended cut that was released On Demand. Unfortunately I have heard that Whedon added most of the jokes that made the movie palatable, I can’t see making that movie MORE serious as being a successful venture, but we certainly shall see.

ThePingMachine
Guest
ThePingMachine

Snyder was apparently happy with the “perfect” cut of the film in 2017, but it clocked in at over four hours long.
If you need four hours to tell a cohesive story, you need to have a better grasp of storytelling. The Snyder cut will suck.

Nuno Fernandes
Guest
Nuno Fernandes

Depends on the story ur telling, there are certain adaptations that would have been better served as a series because there’s so much to tell. although I agree 4h for a Movie is way too much, if all that has to be there, just break it in 2

Robert Loughrey
Guest
Robert Loughrey

I disagree Many movies need to be in longer form. Basically anything that is based on a book of more than 250 pages.

Jay Field
Guest
Jay Field

This comic is FANTASTIC!! *LOL* I JUST posted a rant about this on my FB this morning, actually. With the exception of “Dawn of the Dead” and “300,” and MAYBE “Watchmen” (VERY maybe, and I personally classify it in the following category, the ending missed the ENTIRE POINT of the story), the rest of his directorial career is a slog of tiresome mediocrity and humorlessly grim-dark-edge-lord shaky-cam action and boring predictable drudgery and commercial or critical failure. – Legends of the Guardians: a movie no one knows, no one watched, no one remembers – Sucker Punch: How did he manage… Read more »

Dylan
Guest
Dylan

Honestly this move is more than likely a direct result of no one being able to make new content. This isn’t to appease fans, it’s because Hollywood has no other ideas to make money right now cause they can’t work in the studios. So they’ll take a tone of footage they already recorded and have people work from home to clean it up and release it, but it’ll still be subpar because they won’t be able to access teams the size they normally would for post-production work.

Urazz
Guest
Urazz

I wouldn’t blame Hollywood being stale on the cause of this movie being rereleased with a different cut, but more that DC has no clue what to do with their cinematic universe now because they screwed it up pretty badly but are too prideful to just scrap the whole thing and start over from scratch.

Villainous_Muse
Guest

It’s really ironic to see the inverse of history here. The Avengers exist because JLA was making loads of money and Marvel was like “Hey, we like loads of money!” and copied the cross over idea. Cut to The Avengers MCU film and DC is like “Hey these Marvel movies are making lots of money, we like lots of money!”

It’s odd to see the Bizarro world result that has the DCU totally bombing at the box office but sure, adding a bunch of footage to a crap movie will make it not crap I guess. o_O

Robert Loughrey
Guest
Robert Loughrey

The Avengers is not a crossover movie.

Kaitensatsuma
Guest
Kaitensatsuma

For a second I thought this was about the Tony Hawk 1+2 Remaster.

Kevin
Guest
Kevin

Worked for Superman II for the most part when the Richard Donner cut was released.

Jacob
Guest
Jacob

Superman 1-4 happened despite the issues with #2. Justice League 1 pretty much killed that effort into a franchise, recutting it won’t save it, it can only make it fail less.

Jacob
Guest
Jacob

I’ll watch it if they make it, but other notable successes in this realm (Superman 2 Donner cut and Highlander 2 Renegade edition) saw the franchise moving forward despite these poor offerings. Justice League was supposed to kick off a DCEU, but with Batman already recast and Superman in question, this won’t unring the bell of a franchise ending move.

Urazz
Guest
Urazz

Henry Cavill still wants to be Superman if I recall but was just grossly under used and didn’t get more movies so he started to do his own thing. He might not have time to do it now though since he’s playing Geralt of Rivia in the Witcher now. DC’s loss for not keeping him busy with more Superman movies.

Leon
Guest
Leon

Ewwwwwwwwww, DC superheroes..

Char
Guest
Char

well SOMEBODY hasn’t seen Aquaman, Wonder Woman, or Shazam…

Leon
Guest
Leon

SOMEBODY reminds me of Comic Book Guy from The Simpsons…….

Marcus
Guest
Marcus

while i agree with you tim, they rushed through the process to try and compete with marvel, ill happily sit through ANY comic movie. i do enjoy movies. wife and i watch b-grade movies for the giggles.that being said… ill wait till it is out on my cable service before going out and paying for it.

JJJ
Guest
JJJ

Whats the point?
they would have better luck not making a Batman or Superman or JLA Movie for a while.
Birds of Prey sequel?, I’m in.
Suicide Squad sequel?, I’m in ( lot of actors paydays for that one though).
How bout make a good green lantern movie?
DC got any other Characters they haven’t used yet?

rivenhex
Guest
rivenhex

If I remember correctly, Joss Whedon was brought in because the original cut was called “unwatchable” by test audiences.

Big Johnny
Guest
Big Johnny

The animated DC movies always deliver, but all their big budget crap is always just crap. Never understood it.

Urazz
Guest
Urazz

Man of Steel was pretty good in my opinion (Batman vs Superman sucked though), Wonder Woman was great, Aquaman was good, and Shazam was good as well.

raven0ak
Guest
raven0ak

just different productions, turns out good animator can do wonders only long as its not live acted

Unagiman
Guest
Unagiman

I’m curious about this but I’m really not expecting it to be a transcendental experience. Honestly my biggest problem with the Justice League movie was the way you knew as soon as things seemed darkest Superman would recover and show up to save the day. Superman is just too powerful to really be interesting in most stories to me.

Nuno Fernandes
Guest
Nuno Fernandes

Remember the end of he Man of Steel? That was controvertial because Superman would have found another way, in the eyes of his fans. The interesting thing about Superman is he is so powerful, that its easy to solve any problem, if he doesnt care about the consequences. Its a hard concept to write for, because if you show that he worries too much, it gets boring. If he doesnt care, then it was never a problem to begin with because he is so OP, he wiil find a way to win, and its boring. The 1st Christopher Reeves Superman… Read more »

Him.
Guest
Him.

GenericCo Critic Rating of Justice League: 57%
GenericCo Critic Rating of Justice League: Snyder Cut: 61%

Coffil
Guest
Coffil

I dunno what it is with DC. They always seem to mess up somewhere or maybe it is the choice of Dark feel that superman/batman v S./Justice hero’s are shot in. Instead of the Hope/fun themes their later stuff is shot in like Shazam : pure child wish fulfillment and humor that kinda knew what it was and stuck with it. Aquaman : Drunken stoupor + reluctant King but the change just didnt feel earned Wonderwoman : Hope, seeing the good in people BUT that ending URGH. woulda been better if posion lady just incapacitated enough so she cant stop… Read more »

Urazz
Guest
Urazz

I did like Man of Steel even though it had it’s flaws. I did like how it was a first contact sort of deal with an alien species type of movie in addition to Clark becoming Superman. I always did wonder why there wasn’t more of a reaction to first contact with an alien species.

I agree with the other films though.

EthernetGuru
Member
EthernetGuru

DC/WB need to just stop making various batman movies and spin offs of that character. They have such a big catalog to choose from. Batman should only be part of a JL if included at all.

Urazz
Guest
Urazz

Batman will always be in Justice League since he is part of the holy trinity of DC. It’s not really Justice League if Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman aren’t part of the team.

Rolando
Guest
Rolando

I usually call this somewhat puzzling phenomenon, the “Ivory Tower.” Where, in spite of the entire world telling them (in unison) what they’re doing wrong, and their access to top-notch marketing and research… They just keep on falling off the same cliff. Often enough, their desire for never-ending rivers of money keeps them sharp. But sometimes they just lose it, and it’s confusing for all of us. Maybe they’re just too far removed from the world the rest of us live in? Too surrounded by sycophants, to listen to anybody else? Huge companies often fail to recognise their own resources,… Read more »

Pal87
Guest
Pal87

This was supposed to be DC’s big crossover.

Compared to any of Marvels crossovers, even the unliked age of ultron, and it’s still a pile of steaming dog doodie.

The rAt
Guest
The rAt

I’m not gonna say Snyder is incapable of making a good movie, but he’s definitely capable of making a bad one (see Sucker Punch). People give Wheadon a lot of credit for how poorly Justice League turned out – and to be fair, they may absolutely be right. But Whedon, for me, has a more consistent track record, and more of the things that worked (for me) about Justice League that worked felt like they had his fingerprints on them than Snyder’s. As an example, Justice League is the first DC cinematic movie in which Superman’s personality (in my opinion)… Read more »

Urazz
Guest
Urazz

That’s part of the reason why I’m not really optimistic on this Snyder Cut of Justice League is going to be any better. If anything it might end up being worse in some ways because it would be a lot darker than the version we got.

Some guy who rages
Guest
Some guy who rages

I don’t necessarily think it’s the writers, but more the studio behind it making decisions. I very sincerely doubt the new cut of the movie will be somehow better, I’ve been burned by DC so many times I don’t have faith anymore, but if this IS better, then I hope the execs who thought it was a good idea to introduce Wonderwoman in a Batman V Superman film (packing it in even more densely for some odd reason) would listen up, take a slow deep breath and listen to the film makers. They’ve carved enough money out of fans to… Read more »

raven0ak
Guest
raven0ak

just to say but this is excellent meme template

Jetroid
Guest

Yep, I was expecting the grave to read Fallout 76

W. James
Guest
W. James

This it exactly what I’ve been saying about Star Wars.