I have to admit that I find it frighteningly believable that Nyrah just walks in, sees the transmission, and shoots the transponder before asking questions. To the captain here this looks like sudden gunshot and transmission cut short, so…
This isn’t as clean and smooth as it looks, I believe. I suspect that those of you who see that as polite, honest, professional and successful communication… Are failing to see the politics at play here. I say this, with all due respect. Their entire behavior says: “I don’t believe nor trust a word you utter. I’m just keeping up this facade, to avoid tipping you off to how thoroughly suspicious I find you right now. So, when I make my move, whatever that might be, I hope to beat you to the punch. I know you’re readying yourself for… Read more »
Oh, I see it but it’s more jurisdictional. What they’re actually saying is:
——————————–
Eecko: I see….. That’s odd that you’re out here and I don’t believe that it’s coincidence.
Quel: Well, by virtue of my rank, I don’t answer to you. However, if you REQUIRE assistance, I can come aboard and take over command of your operation.
Eecko: NO, No, not at all. I want to retain operational command……sir.
—————————–
It’s pretty bog-standard territory marking between two ranking officers.
John Swift
1 year ago
Ohh pulling rank, nice. Handled quite well so far. However if Quel tried to really do anything with rank im sure the captain will just use the castor bearer to overrule it.
Gonfrask
1 year ago
The galaxy is not that big…
I must say that I’m waiting to see the reactiom of Nhyra facing Captain Starcaster (sorry, forgot her name).
for all we know, she could snuck up on them, was behind some obstacle and overheard the whole thing. Will then stand with gun in hand and be a little more trusting.
CMasta1992
1 year ago
A misunderstanding cleared up easily and now Nyrah is going to fuck it up
This isn’t as clean and smooth as it looks, I believe. I suspect that those of you who see that as polite, honest, professional and successful communication… Are failing to see the politics at play here. I say this, with all due respect. Their entire behavior says: “I don’t believe nor trust a word you utter. I’m just keeping up this facade, to avoid tipping you off to how thoroughly suspicious I find you right now. So, when I make my move, whatever that might be, I hope to beat you to the punch. I know you’re readying yourself for… Read more »
Not only making an incredibly pretentious comment, but copy & pasting it multiple times.
Classic.
Ben
1 year ago
I immediately don’t trust this captain.
Not sure he’s a Dranglaex spy, but I do think he’s going to do something very stupid in an attempt to make sure HE gets the credit for recovering a Starcaster.
Or… he is an examplary captain from the federation that holds its ideas up above else. The kind the federation is based upon. Not one of the corrupt ones like Cort.
Sasquatch
1 year ago
Ok, I have a couple of genuine questions. It appears to me that the Marshals are both a law enforcement and military agency/unit? Is that right?
Follow up question – what assistance would a single Marshal and ship be able to provide a Federation fleet? Or would the assistance be more like a debrief, to see if he’d picked up and strange transmissions or ship signals while he was in the system?
I think you’re right in the “debriefing and intel” side of assistance, because as you said, a single Marshal and his little fighter aren’t going to be much additional help in any conflict. I’d say you’re right on Marshals being both military and police, while not being military police.
Side note: I personally feel like Marshals have a really high security clearance, and may outrank positions such as Captain, so intel or debriefing from someone in their position might be very welcomed by a Captain.
While the title of Marshal invoked the lone lawman of the old west (independent operation, within the law, and had to be smart to make up for always being out-manned/gunned) — the implications in this conversation seem to lend that in this setting a Marshal is more akin to an Agent in the Firefly universe. A lone operator working to support & uphold The Federation — but one with a tremendous amount of pull (both in clout and available resources). The idea that a lone Marshal might be a needed support agent for a fleet of cruisers or battle-cruisers that… Read more »
I think of them like the Spectres from Mass Effect. They serve the Federation, are highly capable & respected military operators, but are independent from the military command structure.
I think they’re more of an advanced scout and officer – they’re tasked with gathering intelligence and taking out specific dangerous criminals. Something like that. Basically a space CIA type.
So they tend to show up in strange places and when they say “Marshall matters” what they’re really saying is “that’s on a need to know basis, and you don’t need to know”
cryum
1 year ago
Nyrah messing it up with be pretty meh.
If the other starcaster appears and attacks the federation, and now Cort has to decide if he wants to help? THAT would be cool.
Kaitensatsuma
1 year ago
Quel: “I’m here doing ratchet shit”
Captain: “Ah yes, So am I”
Quel: “Indeed? Do you need help”
Captain: “No no No, uh, thank you”
Verdiekus
1 year ago
“These are not the droids you are looking for… Move along….”
foducool
1 year ago
the universe is vast but not that vast, huh
ThatMageGuy
1 year ago
Why do I get the feeling we’re about to have one of those moments where someone acts rashly in order to create artificial drama for the sake of plot? Sure, Nyrah’s probably going to walk in and do something dumb, but not because that actually makes any sense. “Oh look, everything is fine, everything is calm, everyone is using their brains. Can’t have that. Let’s throw in a splash of Unlikely But Catastrophic Events with a dash of Impulsive Stupidity, in order to create a problem that we will then have to solve.” I kinda hate that writing style. It’s… Read more »
But she really doesn’t need to pull the trigger to send all this to hell. Just enter and shouting “Cort! What are you doing? Let’s go!” And this could being hear via video-com for the Captain is enough.
A cycle is a unit of time used throughout the Federation to refer to a standardized day (since an actual day would be different lengths depending on which planet you’re on). Law enforcement/military sometimes have a color of the day code used to identify themselves to fellow members; something an average imposter wouldn’t have access to in the moment.
Kenneth Marticelli
1 year ago
This is going too perfectly normal. Something stupid is going to happen, isn’t it?
Rolando
1 year ago
I suspect that those of you who see that as polite, honest, smooth, professional and successful communication… Are failing to see the politics at play here. I say this, with all due respect. Their entire behavior says: “I don’t believe nor trust a word you utter. I’m just keeping up this facade, to avoid tipping you off to how thoroughly suspicious I find you right now. So, when I make my move, whatever that might be, I hope to beat you to the punch. I know you’re readying yourself for something I won’t like, and so am I for you.”… Read more »
Hey Tim. Got a spammer! We’ll let you handle as is your site. If you want them handled by the fellow commenters just say the word. (The word is ‘Dinnertime’.)
BakaGrappler
1 year ago
Well hey! Look at that! It looks like everything is going to be just fine!
24
Wow, look at how…professional it is!
Sure hope someone doesn’t waltz up offscreen with a gun.
I have to admit that I find it frighteningly believable that Nyrah just walks in, sees the transmission, and shoots the transponder before asking questions. To the captain here this looks like sudden gunshot and transmission cut short, so…
Yup. That sounds about right at this point.
Hopefully, Cort will intercept her and the camera won’t catch the altercation
This isn’t as clean and smooth as it looks, I believe. I suspect that those of you who see that as polite, honest, professional and successful communication… Are failing to see the politics at play here. I say this, with all due respect. Their entire behavior says: “I don’t believe nor trust a word you utter. I’m just keeping up this facade, to avoid tipping you off to how thoroughly suspicious I find you right now. So, when I make my move, whatever that might be, I hope to beat you to the punch. I know you’re readying yourself for… Read more »
Oh, I see it but it’s more jurisdictional. What they’re actually saying is:
——————————–
Eecko: I see….. That’s odd that you’re out here and I don’t believe that it’s coincidence.
Quel: Well, by virtue of my rank, I don’t answer to you. However, if you REQUIRE assistance, I can come aboard and take over command of your operation.
Eecko: NO, No, not at all. I want to retain operational command……sir.
—————————–
It’s pretty bog-standard territory marking between two ranking officers.
Ohh pulling rank, nice. Handled quite well so far. However if Quel tried to really do anything with rank im sure the captain will just use the castor bearer to overrule it.
The galaxy is not that big…
I must say that I’m waiting to see the reactiom of Nhyra facing Captain Starcaster (sorry, forgot her name).
I mean, it IS big, but considering where all the protagonists and antagonists are, it makes sense to cross paths.
for all we know, she could snuck up on them, was behind some obstacle and overheard the whole thing. Will then stand with gun in hand and be a little more trusting.
A misunderstanding cleared up easily and now Nyrah is going to fuck it up
Or the other Starcaster user is going to, or both, devolving the situation into some kind of catfight.
This isn’t as clean and smooth as it looks, I believe. I suspect that those of you who see that as polite, honest, professional and successful communication… Are failing to see the politics at play here. I say this, with all due respect. Their entire behavior says: “I don’t believe nor trust a word you utter. I’m just keeping up this facade, to avoid tipping you off to how thoroughly suspicious I find you right now. So, when I make my move, whatever that might be, I hope to beat you to the punch. I know you’re readying yourself for… Read more »
Not only making an incredibly pretentious comment, but copy & pasting it multiple times.
Classic.
I immediately don’t trust this captain.
Not sure he’s a Dranglaex spy, but I do think he’s going to do something very stupid in an attempt to make sure HE gets the credit for recovering a Starcaster.
Or… he is an examplary captain from the federation that holds its ideas up above else. The kind the federation is based upon. Not one of the corrupt ones like Cort.
Ok, I have a couple of genuine questions. It appears to me that the Marshals are both a law enforcement and military agency/unit? Is that right?
Follow up question – what assistance would a single Marshal and ship be able to provide a Federation fleet? Or would the assistance be more like a debrief, to see if he’d picked up and strange transmissions or ship signals while he was in the system?
Just curious.
Boots on the ground perhaps?
I think you’re right in the “debriefing and intel” side of assistance, because as you said, a single Marshal and his little fighter aren’t going to be much additional help in any conflict. I’d say you’re right on Marshals being both military and police, while not being military police.
Side note: I personally feel like Marshals have a really high security clearance, and may outrank positions such as Captain, so intel or debriefing from someone in their position might be very welcomed by a Captain.
While the title of Marshal invoked the lone lawman of the old west (independent operation, within the law, and had to be smart to make up for always being out-manned/gunned) — the implications in this conversation seem to lend that in this setting a Marshal is more akin to an Agent in the Firefly universe. A lone operator working to support & uphold The Federation — but one with a tremendous amount of pull (both in clout and available resources). The idea that a lone Marshal might be a needed support agent for a fleet of cruisers or battle-cruisers that… Read more »
I think of them like the Spectres from Mass Effect. They serve the Federation, are highly capable & respected military operators, but are independent from the military command structure.
“Do you require assistance?” is just “Can I …..help you?” in italics
He could always offer emotional support
I think they’re more of an advanced scout and officer – they’re tasked with gathering intelligence and taking out specific dangerous criminals. Something like that. Basically a space CIA type.
So they tend to show up in strange places and when they say “Marshall matters” what they’re really saying is “that’s on a need to know basis, and you don’t need to know”
Nyrah messing it up with be pretty meh.
If the other starcaster appears and attacks the federation, and now Cort has to decide if he wants to help? THAT would be cool.
Quel: “I’m here doing ratchet shit”
Captain: “Ah yes, So am I”
Quel: “Indeed? Do you need help”
Captain: “No no No, uh, thank you”
“These are not the droids you are looking for… Move along….”
the universe is vast but not that vast, huh
Why do I get the feeling we’re about to have one of those moments where someone acts rashly in order to create artificial drama for the sake of plot? Sure, Nyrah’s probably going to walk in and do something dumb, but not because that actually makes any sense. “Oh look, everything is fine, everything is calm, everyone is using their brains. Can’t have that. Let’s throw in a splash of Unlikely But Catastrophic Events with a dash of Impulsive Stupidity, in order to create a problem that we will then have to solve.” I kinda hate that writing style. It’s… Read more »
But she really doesn’t need to pull the trigger to send all this to hell. Just enter and shouting “Cort! What are you doing? Let’s go!” And this could being hear via video-com for the Captain is enough.
My name is Quel’oran. Marshal Quel’oran..
why did he say, “This cycle’s color is silver”?
A cycle is a unit of time used throughout the Federation to refer to a standardized day (since an actual day would be different lengths depending on which planet you’re on). Law enforcement/military sometimes have a color of the day code used to identify themselves to fellow members; something an average imposter wouldn’t have access to in the moment.
This is going too perfectly normal. Something stupid is going to happen, isn’t it?
I suspect that those of you who see that as polite, honest, smooth, professional and successful communication… Are failing to see the politics at play here. I say this, with all due respect. Their entire behavior says: “I don’t believe nor trust a word you utter. I’m just keeping up this facade, to avoid tipping you off to how thoroughly suspicious I find you right now. So, when I make my move, whatever that might be, I hope to beat you to the punch. I know you’re readying yourself for something I won’t like, and so am I for you.”… Read more »
Hey Tim. Got a spammer! We’ll let you handle as is your site. If you want them handled by the fellow commenters just say the word. (The word is ‘Dinnertime’.)
Well hey! Look at that! It looks like everything is going to be just fine!